Timeline

Appeals court upholds the Pentagon's exclusion of Anthropic under a second statute

A 2-1 panel held Claude's built-in usage restrictions could count as a supply-chain risk; Anthropic sought full-court rehearing on 13 October, backed by 17 former national security officials.

  • Courts & copyright
  • Government & policy
  • Notable

A panel of the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit upheld, by two votes to one, the Department of War’s order excluding Anthropic and its Claude models from department systems and contractor work. The Pentagon had designated the company a supply-chain risk in March after Anthropic refused to drop its restrictions on fully autonomous weapons and domestic mass surveillance, relying on two separate statutes litigated in two courts. In August a San Francisco district judge struck down the designation made under 10 U.S.C. § 3252, whose definition of supply-chain risk centres on an “adversary”. The D.C. Circuit’s ruling concerned the other designation, under the Federal Acquisition Supply Chain Security Act (FASCSA), which defines the risk more broadly as one that “any person” might sabotage or manipulate.

Judge Gregory Katsas, joined by Judge Neomi Rao, held that the department “had ample support for its conclusion that the continued integration of Claude into the Department’s information systems, by the Department or its contractors, presented a statutorily covered national-security risk”, according to the opinion. The majority accepted that restrictions trained into a model could constrain military operations even though Anthropic could not alter a model after deployment, noting Secretary Pete Hegseth’s concern about “overly constrained” models. Holland & Knight’s summary noted the panel also found the order was prompted by a specific contract dispute rather than Anthropic’s public safety advocacy, and treated the department’s failure to follow notice procedures as harmless error.

Judge Karen LeCraft Henderson dissented. According to Clark Hill, she read the statute as aimed at deliberately subversive conduct by hostile actors, not openly disclosed usage restrictions.

The court stayed its judgment for seven days so Anthropic could seek rehearing by the full circuit, which it did on 13 October, petitioning the D.C. Circuit to rehear the case en banc. The district court’s injunction against the separate § 3252 designation still stands, so the outcome remains split.

The petition argued the panel had read “otherwise manipulate” too broadly, covering any deliberate design choice rather than the hostile, covert compromise Congress had targeted in cases like Kaspersky and Huawei — a reading under which, as Lawfare’s analysis of the filing put it, “nearly any deliberate design choice could qualify as manipulation and expose any company to being labeled as a supply chain risk.” On 20 October, a bipartisan group of 17 former senior national security officials, diplomats and intelligence professionals, among them Avril Haines, Susan Rice and Jake Sullivan, filed a 26-page brief urging the full court to rehear the case, DefenseScoop reported, dating the filing to Tuesday. They argued that because Congress gave the D.C. Circuit exclusive jurisdiction over such designations, the panel’s ruling would be the nationwide rule that “no other court can revisit”, and that “left undisturbed that ruling will threaten all defense contractors”. They also argued the rationale was pretextual and the designation retaliation for Anthropic’s public positions. A ruling on whether the full court would hear the case was pending.

In the commentary

What people were saying around this time — external links, from the record's commentary rail.